Ali Responds

Ali demonstrates that he does, in fact, have a bit of integrity after all.  He has responded to my post, as I reproduce here.  I still await his reciprocity on his site (posting at least a symbolic link to my article critiquing his conduct on the Inner City Christian Discernment Ministry website), but in lieu of such, this is a welcomed start.
 
My response to Ali will be shortly forthcoming; at the moment I am engaged in responding to another Mohammedian, which article will also soon be posted here.  For now, however, let the debate continue...
 

From: "Ali Aman" <MAHMEDO@prodigy.net>
To: <ixthys@usa.net>
Subject: Challenge.
Date: Thu, 28 May 1998 00:06:20 -0500
Message-ID: <01bd89f6$5afe0940$120e48a6@default>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/alternative;
 boundary="----=_NextPart_000_0004_01BD89CC.72280140"
X-Priority: 3
X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express 4.71.1712.3
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V4.71.1712.3

 
First of all if your gospel is the truth then why do you have to defend it.
Isn't that the purpose of your website? Isn't its title "In Practical Defense of
the Gospel of Jesus Christ"? Secondly we shouldn't be called "Mohammedian's".
We dont worship Mohammed (pbuh) in any way or wish to do so. We regard all the
 Prophets as only Prophets and we dont have any difference between any one of them
such as between Mohammed and Jesus and Abraham and  Noah etc.. (pbut).
To us the only reason that the prophets were send down upon us was a reminder from god
to bring us to the straight path from such evil practices such as idol worshipping or worshipping
more than one god. One more thing that you stated on your challenge page was that we have a moon god.
"(the moon god of Islam prohibits its followers to question it or it's book -- the Qu'ran -- or it's "prophet") "
there is no such thing as a moon god or sun god in Islam. Allah created everything and he is the only god.
we worship none but Allah the one god and the only. the one that doesnt need a son or any body.
why does God need help from a son if he is the Al-Mighty and Divine. Couldnt he do everything
his self such as creating the earth. If Jesus as you say is God then where was he during the time
of Adam and Eve there is no mention of him in the gospel. you also said that i believe i am going to heaven because im righteous, well i dont know and no Muslims know that is all in the order of god. we will all be judged on the last day so it is not
right or even lawful in Islam for any Muslim to say that he for sure is going to heaven it is all up to god.i had no intention of creating any problems by posting that stuff on that Christian website.  none of it was made up and it had verses from the  bible to prove
it wasn't made up. you can even check for your self that it isn't even there so dont tell the people on your website its there.i think you exaggerated a little in this challenge and of your defense and i wish we could discuss anything with out any challenges or any insults such as that i have  no integrity. i didn't insult you in any way or wish to do so so please dont exaggerate this over the limit.
Also dont forget to post this on your website so you could show both arguments to your viewers and i am willing to put your arguments on my page. May Allah Forgive you and Have Mercy on you.
 
 

Continue on to my First Rebuttal